How to : Furnish Your House with Old Furniture
All of the guest writers that have dropped by to say hi on Making This Home these last few months have just AMAZED me. This next guest maintains that awwwe factor with a million awesome tips. Jane from The Borrowed Abode is here to talk about used furniture.
I’ll be honest; two months ago, I had no idea how much furniture cost in the US. I started fearing that Martin and I would be using cardboard file boxes for tables. Then I saw Jane’s living room…. Jane’s $750 living room. I just had to know…
Jane, how on earth do you affordably furnish your house with old stuff and make it look so cool?
![]()

Hi everyone! I’m Jane from The Borrowed Abode, where I blog about decorating my rental home on a small budget, and starting my own business. One of my favorite ways to decorate thriftily is to work with thrifted, vintage, and sometimes straight-up-free furniture when possible while only welcoming pieces that I truly love into my home.
I’m so flattered that Katie trusted me to share some of my tips on decorating with second-hand furniture. In fact, I bet it’s perfect timing, since she’s working on her exciting airplane hangar-turned-apartment renovation project! (Hmm. I wonder if she’ll find any fun vintage furniture while cleaning out the space?)
To me, the best parts of decorating with vintage and thrifted furniture are the stories that accompany each addition.
My boyfriend and I have been furnishing our home for the last year and a half, and I’m amazed to look around and see that almost everything in our house has a story behind it – and by story I don’t mean “we drove to Macy’s and bought this couch brand new.”
Our furniture stories are more like “Oh, I remember this lamp. We found it in that cute little town in New Hampshire, right after we had that tasty breakfast at the old Mill, and before we went on the hike up that mountain.” Or Ryan would say “Oh, I remember this chair. Jane made me help her carry it home from the neighbor’s garbage pile, and it was 100 degrees out that day.”
I just love the memories that we are bringing into our home – both the serious and silly ones. And chances are, if you’re already a regular reader of Making This Home, then you’re probably interested in saving some money, respecting the environment, and embracing a good story. So let’s see how you can do all that while furnishing your home!
First, let’s start with the most important part. Why buy used?
- It saves you money!
- It’s often better for the environment!
- It’s not made with the sketchy and ethically questionable labor situations that run rampant overseas. (FYI, even some of the “fancy” furniture stores sell furniture made overseas.)
- Vintage pieces especially are often sturdier, constructed of solid wood, and just much more durable.
Example: None of the furniture in my living room (below) was bought new – that’s how we managed to create this space for less than $750. While that’s still a lot of money (to me, at least), it was totally doable over the course of a year or two.

Where do you find *good* used furniture, without paying an arm and a leg for an antique?
- Unless you live in a very remote area, Craigslist is your BFF. If I’m looking for a specific item, I usually start here. And if you use the CraigsEasy tool, it’s super easy to view large photos right there in your search results. No extra clicking necessary. :)
- Thrift stores! If the first store or two that you try doesn’t seem to have much furniture, don’t give up! Try a few more, becuase you’ll find that some locations have more furniture, while others are focused primarily on clothes. And don’t just go to the major Goodwill and Salvation Army stores – look on Yelp.com or just plain Google to find the smaller, lesser-known shops. They’re often run as fundraisers for your local humane society, rotary club, or other community organization.
- Yard Sales can provide killer bargains on used furniture, because people are decluttering and don’t want to lug leftovers back into their house after the sale. We found an amazing mid-century modern coffee table for about $10 at one, just by doing an accidental drive-by.
- Consignment furniture stores usually offer up furniture with less wear and tear, and from very high quality makers, but of course you’ll pay the price. However, you will still save a bundle compared to what a high-quality piece would cost new!
- Curbside Trash Picking! Probably the most controversial of all my tips, it’s one of my personal favorites. It can be one of the thriftiest and most fun ways to furnish a room! In our town (and many others around us) it’s common for people to put their unwanted bulk items (furniture, etc) on the curb. Technically, the city comes around with a truck once in a while and picks the trash up – but usually all the good stuff (and stuff with potential to be made good) is picked up by people looking to give the items a new home.
Example: We found this sweet mid-century modern stereo cabinet / storage unit this way, and are planning on refinishing it as a wedding gift for our good friends.

When shopping for thrifted/secondhand/vintage furniture:
- Take your time. You’ll often find “good deals” on furniture at the venues mentioned above – but if it’s not a piece that you need for your home, or it’s not really your style, don’t get it “just because it’s such a good deal.” If I could go back in time about 10 years and tell myself this, it would really have helped my budget!
- To avoid making the above mistakes, before you shop – Prioritize! What pieces do you need most in your house? It helps to keep a short list in your purse or wallet, specifying what pieces you are looking for (along with measurements of what will fit your space), or what storage/decorating challenges you need to tackle. This way you can make sure you leave the shop with only what you need!
- Seek out the lesser known thrift stores – Goodwill and Salvation Army are great, but most places have smaller, independent stores – often run by charities such as the Lyons Club or the local animal welfare organization. These often have lesser-known furniture stashes, and while their selection may be smaller, they often yield top-notch results!
- Consider what imperfections you can deal with. If you’re a DIYer, then you can fix up just about any item. If you’re not a DIYer then it may take you longer to find just what you need, but it’s still totally feasible.
- Before you dish out the dough for the furniture, always make sure to inspect its condition. I learned this the hard way, when I failed to inspect the underside of an item until we were loading it into the car. We’d have asked for a lower price if we’d seen the cracks in the base before purchase.
- Psst: In all of the venues listed above, you can usually negotiate and save even more money.
Example: By taking my time and knowing exactly what I wanted in a living room sofa, I was able to get this $1600 Crate and Barrel sofa used on Craigslist for only $300. Why? Because there’s a hole in the upholstery on one arm. I simply covered it with a cozy throw blanket. Perfect!

I’ve got the used furniture, now what do I do with it?
Before you bring your sweet scores into your home, take these steps to ensure no “unwanted guests” sneak into your home with the furniture. Go with your gut. If the home or store you found your treasures in seemed clean and well cared-for, then a simple vacuuming or dusting once you bring the furniture home should suffice. But if you found old, grungy, upholstered furniture on the side of the road, here’s what to do before bringing it inside your home (or shortly after):
- Take photos of every angle. This way you’ll have a record of how it looked if / when you (or a professional) want to reupholster it.
- Strip every bit of upholstery off, leaving you with the wood frame (and maybe springs). This way, you ensure you’ve removed any of the materials that may have been harboring pests.
- Wipe it down with a damp rag and maybe some cleaning spray, depending on how dusty and dirty the frame is.
What’s the best type of used furniture to buy?
- Dressers, bookshelves, desks, tables, china cabinets - these are some of the best pieces to buy. And if you need more storage in room (like a living room), dressers or credenzas are the easiest way to add it. Just make it your own (with paint, hardware, or new varnish – see below) and then use it as a TV stand/ entertainment center or pop it behind your sofa as a “sofa table.” The drawers and hidden shelves in dressers and credenzas offer killer hidden storage space!
What should you [probably] avoid buying used?
- Mattresses and box springs: I know some may disagree with me, but for sanitary reasons I’d probably never buy these used. Especially with the bedbug situations these days. (If you’re on a very low budget, 5″ upholstery foam makes a great affordable mattress. I know this because I put the foam over a piece of plywood on cinder-block legs for my bed in my first apartment.)
- Baby cribs: I don’t have kids, but when I do, I’ll spend whatever it takes to get a safe, sturdy new crib and mattress for my baby. So many older cribs have been recalled for safety issues – so I wouldn’t want to take a chance.
How can you make the secondhand furniture work in your house?
- New Hardware: If the wood finish is in good shape, but the hardware makes it look dated, considering switching out the hardware. Changing from old brassy drawer pulls to sleek chrome modern knobs can make a world of difference.
- New Wood Stain: If the wood finish is the wrong color, but the piece is solid wood, you can refinish it to a darker or lighter stain.
- Paint: When all else fails, paint can transform anything! If you like to keep things simple, a white or cream color works wonders. But I am really loving all the brightly colored pieces I’m seeing around the blogosphere right now. I just need to find a good candidate to paint green or orange for my house. ;)
Need inspiration? Searching for “painted furniture” on Pinterest will yield boatloads of inspiration. I’m constantly amazed at how ugly old dressers and desks can be utterly transformed with a fun coat of paint! For tutorials on painting old furniture, Kate at Centsational Girl is my go-to blogger. She’s got a slew of great info and tutorials on her blog. One of my favorite examples is this $40 office credenza that she transformed with a few coats of paint and new hardware.
Kate at Centsational Girl transformed this $40 thrift store piece with new hardware and a few coats of paint!
In the end, furnishing your home with a mix of vintage and thrifted furnishings may take a bit longer and require a bit more elbow grease, but in the end I think it’s absolutely worth it! Not only is older furniture often more sturdy and durable, it will save you a ton of money and provide you with memories that last a lifetime.
Now it’s your turn. Any awesome old finds at your house? How about the dream of some?
And a huge thank you to Miss Jane!








Another great source for second-hand furniture is Habitat for Humanity’s ReStore – and shopping there supports a good cause. They also have sinks, cabinets, counter tops, paint, etc. – anything that can be re-used. http://www.habitat.org/restores/default.aspx?tgs=Ny8yOC8yMDExIDk6MDc6NTYgQU0%3d
Also a great place to donate your unwanted furniture or building supplies. The store in our town will even pick-up items.
This is a fantastic post; thorough and organized! Way to go Jane! This is exactly how I furnished my US homes before moving overseas. I cannot tell you how much I miss trash picking and Craigslist, etc. I would have to go a major German city to find a flea market with decent and affordable furniture, but it’s nice to remember the ‘good old days’ of furniture shopping in the US =) I’m looking forward to seeing how Katie’s place develops over time!
While my home is not as put together as Miss Jane’s, however, everything around me was either given to me or found very cheaply, except my bed, which we bought new. Once people know you are looking for stuff, it will find you! You’ll end up having to tell people to stop trying to give you more. :-) I am enjoying the process of your hanger being made into a home. I can totally see it happening and can’t wait to rejoice with you when it does!
This is awesome. Our favorite used pieces are a vintage leather chair and footstool that we got at yard sale for $50.
Wondeful post with awesome advice! I couldn’t agree more! Jane rocks my socks!
xoxo
Cat
@BudgetBlonde
Wow! I love this post! Great tips, Jane, I had no idea about CraigsEasy. I will be using that from now on. We refer to my grandmother’s basement as the “gift shop” because she has all sorts of fun stuff in there from various places. We took an old set of her nesting end tables, sanded, spray painted, and TA DA, instant furniture update for almost no cost. Kate and Jane – you girls are inspiring!
This list is officially printed out and beside a highlighter!
Everything but the recliner and TV cabinet in my living room was used… and the TV cabinet only because we specifically wanted one with glass doors to keep little baby fingers out of the equipment. Last weekend, I scored for $20 a wooden platform spring rocking chair at a yard sale! Cushions look newer, just needs to have the wood painted. I also have the wood buffet table that my mom had when I was a kid. It used to be brown with chipped veneer… now it is a lovely shade of dark purple. I LOVE it!
But, I must disagree about the baby bed thing. While most big box store brand baby beds bought used probably is not a good idea, we found a 20 year old bed from a local shop in Wisconsin that was superior to anything currently being made new. The original maker is no longer in business, but I checked out all of the safety regs and my crib passed them all with flying colors. And, at $70, it was a much better deal than what I could have bought new. And, just because it is new does not guarantee that it will not have serious defects found after you buy it – and it is hard to keep up with all of the recalls even on new stuff! And, if push comes to shove, you can always research the safety rules and make your own crib – nothing is saying that store bought is better, and often it is much worse.
Great article!
When we were younger we were always very open to free furniture. (Still am – but I think we need less – and people are less apt to offer when you aren’t in your teens or 20s!)
Of course, we didn’t have to put any elbow grease into the nice pieces of furniture that our friends and family tired of, outgrew, or could no longer use for whatever reason. We have my parent’s grand piano, and a bright blue couch that we did buy because it was a *great deal* new. Not that it really matches anything, but we do like it! We bought our current home around the time Grandma downsized, and so we inherited a dining set, china cabinet, and a washer/dryer (I am also a big believer in used appliances). Dining nook was furnished with a table my roommate left and chairs a co-worker no longer wanted. The table is plain but has always had a pretty table clothe. The chairs are GORGEOUS. We did buy a nice/new sectional couch early on in our marriage, but this was largely because my old couch could not fit through the door in our first condo. It’s the only thing I remember buying when we moved in together. Everyone told us we would spend a fortune on furniture – first home and second home which was twice as big. (Not true!). Oh yes – I forgot we have a recliner that we saved from the trash bin (my sister was going to throw it in the dumpster – it was a perfectly NICE new-ish chair!)
We’ve got several hand-me-downs (from childhood/early adulthood) dispersed through our upstaris (3 bedrooms and one den).
I mostly like how not focusing on the *new* has freed up money for far more important things. As I alluded, most my friends think I am delusional, because I don’t understand why you have to buy anything just because you move into a bigger space. :D (& believe me – we did NOT furnish our current home overnight – it took years). BUT, I had never thought much about it before – you are so right – every furniture acquisition has a story behind it. Makes it extra special.
I furnished my entire studio for less than $400.00 using Craigslist, thrift shops and street finds and I always get comments on how nice my space is. The only new items are the full sized mattress set and love seat I got from a furniture closing for only $250.00. My favorite finds are a round dining table purchased at a yard sale for $25.00 and three mismatched chairs I got for $3.00 each. A 1/2 gallon of Chinese red paint and I have a set that would easily go for over $300.00. My retro 50′s bedroom set I got from craigslist for $75.00 which included a pair of nightstands, rails, headboard and 6 drawer dresser and mirror. The rug, club chair and trunk that I use for a coffee table and drapes were all from Freecycle and the computer desk and alot of my cookware and dishes came from a box left by the dumpster on moveout day. I LOVE free and cheap finds, especially when I know that I am keeping these things from the landfill.
We are building a house and using as many free/craigslist finds as we possibly can. Although, in the beginning, we had hoped to find framing & actual “building materials” from such places, with the building schedule (and the fact that we don’t know much about framing/foundations), it just proved to be too much. BUT…once the house was underroof, we have TONS of stuff to finish it up. From kitchen cabinets (refinished), to toilets, to brand new wood flooring (from a craigslist ad clearing out a warehouse)…we’ve saved over $30k in just finishing supplies alone. (possibly more)
We’ve had such a great time browsing clearance aisles, e-classified ads, craigslist, freecycle (and curbside finds)! Some say we’re crazy (others probably thinks it’s disgusting using other people’s leftovers), but we feel we’re doing a small part to keep things out of the landfill while using the money we’ve been given responsibly. I would like to think that even if our budget weren’t an issue with our build, that we’d do the same thing….
wow great post, i love how inspirational it is!