Polishing Silver Naturally
If we lived somewhere with malls, this probably wouldn’t have happened. Never mind if we had stores that sell absolutely nothing but organizing equipment!
I suspect if we lived near a Walmart this wouldn’t have happened.
Heck, I might have even stopped at a KMart. But we didn’t have that either. So this is what happened instead.
I needed a few decorative containers for storage. Where oh where to go? Ah ha! I found these really cool silver-plated dishes at the only container store I could think of in town: the thrift shop.

Silver is pretty much the last thing you’d expect to put in a tire house. (I’m thinking hubcap fruit bowls would fit a little better.) But I didn’t have any used hubcaps, and I don’t want any thanks-so-much. I’m going to give the silver a shot, though. Their price tags pretty much did me in. They spelled L-O-V-E:

One for $2.50, $2.00, and $1.00! All three dishes for only $5.50? Yes please.
Then the clerk did something incredible. She slashed the price by 22%. ”It’s Arctic Blast Discount Day!” she said with a warm grin. A 22% discount for going out in 22 degree F weather? (-6 C) Double the yeses. So I happily walked back to our car, mailed all of your lovely journals, stocked up on groceries, and zipped back to the country with my loot.
The only problem with my silver was the intense tarnish all over it. You can probably guess that I don’t have silver polish at home. Meanwhile, I’m guessing that I probably couldn’t find polish very easily in town. So in walked Mr. Google.

Apparently you can polish silver with one basic ingredient: baking soda! I read two theories and worked on them simultaneously to buff up my bootie:
1. Line a pot with aluminum foil, add a bunch of baking soda, and heat the water. Drop in your silver and let sit. Wipe off any remaining tarnish spots with a cloth and rinse.
2. Build a baking soda and water paste. Massage into silver and rinse.
Off I went, heating water, polishing with baking soda – the whole works.

Already a huge difference! Can you see the tarnished areas versus where the grim has already come off?

Polishing silver is a lost art. To watch the experienced women in my family has always felt like watching beauty – like kneading bread or hand stitching. It’s moving. It’s watching something that’s so comfortable to their hands. It’s the creation of something restored and beautiful.
To watch me?
Let’s just say: wear goggles. There may be a few unidentifiable chunks of goo flying as I buff away.
Then again, maybe not. You can probably stop by without goggles for now.
We’re out of baking soda.








January 12th, 2011 at 4:06 pm
That’s awesome! And damn, hubcap fruit bowls would have ROCKED. :) But like you said, make do with what you have.
I was just getting ready for a post on polishing silver. I may still do it, because I use something else from the home, but I’ll be sure to mention your method too! :)
January 12th, 2011 at 4:31 pm
Great! I have some silver that needs to be polished and I did not want to buy silver polish that I would rarely use and that is full of chemicals. Off I go to polish my few pieces of silver. Thanks Katie, you are wonderful!!!
January 12th, 2011 at 5:13 pm
Jane – some combination with the baking soda is bound to work. I’m just not sure what that is. Some help, huh?! :)
Katie
January 13th, 2011 at 8:49 am
Love the reclaimed silver! I’ve used lemon juice with the baking soda for my paste and it worked amazingly well on a gunky copper tea kettle. Will try straight soda next time!
Thx fir the comment @ 16balls!
Blessings!
Lib
January 14th, 2011 at 4:02 am
Nice silver dishes!
You wouldn’t find them here (Belgium) for that price!
You can also try it with toothpaste.
I use it on my silver jewelry and it is amazing what comes off. They look like new.
Good luck!
Nathalie
January 14th, 2011 at 4:03 am
Forgot to add that I use an old toothbrush with it.
January 14th, 2011 at 6:34 am
Those are beautiful finds! I found that silver polishing method in Real Simple magazine a few years ago and have used it a couple of times to great success.
Laura in Ludwigsburg
January 14th, 2011 at 1:46 pm
Those are some great dishes. I have memories of polishing the silver with my grandmother – for some reason I liked it, so she would pull it out for me to polish even if it didn’t need it. Her honeymoon souvenir was a little spoon pin, which she gave me shortly before she died, and it’s one of the most special things I have now. I seem to have lost my love for polishing though, it seems. I love the hot water/aluminum foil/baking soda trick, that’s what I use for my silver jewelry.
January 19th, 2011 at 6:22 am
I agree with Nathalie about using toothpaste and an old toothbrush. I try to use toothpaste with baking soda in t, altough basic crest will work in a pinch. It’s a trick I learned from my grandmother when I was just a little girl. Also, use a polishing cloth (like you use on jewelry) or a piece of flannel to shne them when you are done.
And those are some amazingly beautiful pieces you picked up there!
July 7th, 2011 at 4:43 pm
One of my old classmates in a museum studies class did a project comparing the various methods of polishing silver (stuff marketed as silver polish vs. the hot water/foil/soda vs. toothpaste) and what had the best effect (defined as least silver loss, scratching, and/or microscopic pitting) was the toothpaste. Has to be the white kind, not gel, as it’s really the calcium carbonate in the toothpaste that’s doing the heavy lifting. The hot water/foil/soda thing redeposits silver globs unevenly back onto the piece, which is fine once in a while, but not something you really want to do long-term and repeatedly.
July 7th, 2011 at 4:45 pm
Thanks for the tips. Toothpaste is next!
I certainly had the nasty clumping going on.
Katie