The No New Clothes Challenge : Late Summer Update
Yikes! Have several months really gone by since our latest No New Clothes Challenge update? Yowzers.
To help refresh your memory, last May Martin and I decided to stop buying new clothes. The plan was to go the entire summer without buying any clothes. But then going without new clothes became a habit. Fast forward to today – over a year later! – and we’re still not buying clothes.
Sure, we’re buying the occasional socks, gloves, or undershirts when they’re needed. But clothing shopping just for the heck of it? NOPE. Clothing shopping because we might like something new? NOPE. And you know what? It’s been the greatest year ever.
- I’m wearing the clothes I have.
- I’m not feeling tempted by what advertisements show I’m supposed to dress like.
- I don’t feel like I’m missing out or out of place. I’m feeling like me – and that’s the greatest feeling of all.

Many of you have asked different questions about our year without clothes shopping. Here’s my shot at answering everything.
How did moving overseas TWICE over the last year change The No New Clothes Challenge?
We took our favorite clothes to Germany. Everything else was boxed up, so we wore the same sweaters constantly. The biggest question I received was, “Don’t you get tired of wearing the same clothes over and over?” As it turns out, my classmates learning German with me were also wearing the same clothes a lot more often than I ever saw in the US. I fell in love with their philosophy on clothes: Wear what you love, and love what you own. Don’t bother with any other clothes.
Moving back to the US was hard. We brought our favorite clothes and all our pants back. But we got here and realized we had no socks in the US, so I had to go buy some. I’d been darning our socks all winter, so part of me was sad to buy all new. Another part of me was relieved – no darning for at least a few months!
Do you have a huge stash of clothes we don’t know about?
No way! I have two average plastic bins worth of clothes in the US plus winter supplies (like a down coat and thick mittens, which are a must around here but not in Berlin) and a few dresses.
One bin is unpacked. The other I decided to keep for rotating clothes or visiting for something “new” to wear.
When you box up anything for a period of time, you find that you don’t need the stuff. Or when you do pull it out, it’s so much more interesting to you than if it had been on the bottom of your closet the whole time.
You said you had a July wedding to go to. What did you do?
I wore something I already had from a friend’s wedding (far right in photo, cracking up). I also contemplated hemming a bridesmaid dress into an evening dress.

How do you still keep resisting new clothes?
Honestly, not shopping for clothes has become a habit. I don’t want to go back to that feeling that I’ll never be satisfied with my clothes - which is how I felt when I was always buying clothes to try and fit current fashions.
In some ways, when you aren’t satisfied with your clothes, you start feeling unsatisfied with yourself.
It also helps to have something you’re saving up for. Each time you’re tempted to buy a little new piece of clothing, think about that dream item. Would you rather have the new clothes or keep working toward having that dream come true sooner?

Now it’s your turn. Have you been thinking about clothes and your relationship with them like at our house? How has your clothing shopping been going this summer?
Catch the whole No New Clothes journey right here – where I spill decisions like only buying handmade jewelry to learning ways to make what I already have feel special, even if I’m the only non-tourist wearing a bright! coat in Germany.








August 2nd, 2010 at 8:36 am
I love your posts on the No New Clothes challenge! My relationship with clothes this summer has been quite emotional, since I just had a baby, and although most of my tops still fit, bottoms are a different story. The first month, I still wore maternity clothes, but as those got too big and I realized that I needed something to wear to work in a few weeks, I did a mini shopping spree at Old Navy. There has been at least one meltdown of “I don’t have anything to wear” before the shopping spree, so I think it was money well spent!
And I’ve realized now that before, I had WAY too many clothes, and have decided to drastically cut back. I’ve gotten rid of the majority of old pants and skirts (most of which didn’t fit that well pre-pregnancy). I’ve kept a few expensive pieces that don’t currently fit, just in case I ever get back to my previous size. And I love that my closet and drawers are much less full. I’ve found that I really only need 1 pair of jeans (since I can’t wear them to work), 2-3 work pants, 1 skirt…So, not only do I want to avoid excessive buying like you do, but I also love that I’ve pared down the basics.
August 2nd, 2010 at 9:12 am
Katie, thanks for the update :) you continue to be a “no-clothes-buying” inspiration! its been TWO MONTHS now & i’m still going strong (it helps to have teenaged sisters who give me “hand me ups”!) with NO desire to buy new clothes. i’ve realized that i need to TAKE AWAY the temptations–i unsubscribed from all the catalogs & email updates from jcrew, etc. that seemed to flood my email inbox (& conscience) almost daily.
here is my question: i am totally tracking the whole concept of NOT buying clothes (something tangible, temporary) in order to save for something bigger. BUT do you put the money aside that you WOULD have spent on clothes? or does it all just sit there? I tend to talk myself into buying item “X” that is on SALE because well, it is cheaper–but i never actually put the money aside that i *would* have spent had i bought it full price. and if i love it enough to take it home, i’m not sure if it should matter if it is on sale (in other words, i WOULD have paid full price if i LOVED it that much!).
AND…my husband & i were listening to Dave Ramsey a couple of days ago when a couple called in from Germany (former military). Dave mentioned that German’s tend to be frugal-natured people. So could you tell us sometime the things you’ve noticed by-and-large about Germans that ARE frugal? What do they do that is so different that makes them so?
Thanks!
August 2nd, 2010 at 12:01 pm
way to go, ladies!
jja – I will certainly think about frugality in Germany vs. the US and what I’ve experienced. You have my mind spinning.
Katie
August 2nd, 2010 at 4:39 pm
Well, I went one month without buying any clothes, which was a decent accomplishment for me. I broke that fast yesterday, on vacation, when I spied a beautiful sundress that just caught my eye. I decided to go for it, but only after finding out where it was made and that the workers were treated fairly. I’ve become increasingly concerned with that since the winter, when I started really thinking about how goods are manufactured.
You’ve definitely been an inspiration, and I’m finding my mindset slowly changing, as I continue to shop less and less. I have enough clothes, for sure.
August 2nd, 2010 at 5:52 pm
We just got back from a 3 1/2 week camping trip. I packed 4 outfits for each of us, plus PJs & swimsuits. We did fine with it, and since I’ve been home, I feel completely overwhelmed by stuff… All I can think about it getting rid of things. Not just clothes, but those definitely need a paring down!
August 2nd, 2010 at 7:19 pm
I’m reading “No Impact Man” right now and it hits the right spot for me. I don’t feel like buying anything new these days, and the things I do buy (food, toiletries) I try to buy with no packaging. However, this is something my kids need to get used to. I have a 14 year old daughter who is clothes crazy and we end up disagreeing about buying second-hand clothes as a compromise. But I’m working on her….
August 2nd, 2010 at 8:14 pm
Oh thanks for the update! I have been doing a combination of not buying new clothes, and getting rid of the clothes I really just don’t wear, despite all my beliefs that I will wear them someday. I have one twist, though: I love wearing skirts and dresses, and I am learning to sew…so I am allowed to ‘get’ a new dress or skirt, but only if I make it. So that’s fun!
August 2nd, 2010 at 9:00 pm
I love it when you update about this challenge. About twice a year I try to go through my closet and get rid of things I never use, which always feels great, but somehow there are still plenty of items left behind! And there are special items that I don’t want to give away, in the hopes of one day wearing them again, but I have been very very picky about those and only keep a few packed away for that hopeful day . . .
Having just gone through pregnancy and now almost 8 months of post birth body, I definitely shopped, for nursing tops specifically, and pants that actually FIT! But I am hoping to pack them away and use it all again in another year or two . . .
Reading about what you have been doing and how it is going is definitely inspirational, thank you for sharing! :)
August 2nd, 2010 at 9:27 pm
Your purple dress is gorgeous!
I’ve been losing weight and every time I go down another size, I give away the clothes that don’t fit and go to goodwill or other thrift stores and buy workout clothes, a pair of jeans, a pair of pants, three nice tops and a couple of shirts to wear to bed. If I worked in an office, I’d obviously have to buy professional clothes too. I buy underclothes at new stores (just can’t buy that second hand :)
When you have to buy an entire new wardrobe every 6 weeks or so, you really realize how little you need.
August 3rd, 2010 at 9:56 am
huge applauses coming from our house and to all of you!
August 5th, 2010 at 7:19 am
i think it’s a good challenge to do for a while. just to remind yourself to be mindful. sort of similar to people who fast for a few days and then say it sorta reset the way they think about food. we shouldn’t just grab, or buy, things out of habit.
August 5th, 2010 at 8:01 pm
Hi Katie, thanks so much for stopping by my blog. :) I came over to skim yours a bit and stopped at this post. I haven’t spent my own money on new clothes in so long, it’s so great. I mostly wear the same stuff over and over. I do buy new clothes, but just once or twice a year with gift cards from mom/grandma, and I ONLY buy clearance. I don’t know if it’s because we don’t have a lot of money, or maybe just the way I was raised.
Mom never bought us new clothes but maybe a couple of outfits at christmas and back-to-school. I remember how hard it was on me keeping up with fashion. I guess as I grew up I hated the way I felt about myself because of what I WASN’T wearing, you know? Now I just want clothes that fit, even if that means peeking over in the plus size department now and then to face my post-twins body. ;P
Oh! And I just saw jlyn’s comment about frugal germans… my husband is german and won’t spend money on ANYTHING! I’ve become pretty frugal myself after 9 years of marriage, but we still argue when he wants to bring food for the kids to a restaurant, or make all three girls share one kids meal… and popcorn at the movies… FORBIDDEN. :) Seriously, I say we might as well stay home if we’re not going to experience eating out or a night at the movies. Wait. We’ve never been to movies at night. Matinees only. LOL, he’s a crack up. I think for him it’s something to do with not having much money as a kid and maybe a genetic and slightly irrational fear of being poor. I’d be interested to hear your thoughts living among “real” Germans!
August 11th, 2010 at 9:03 am
In Janurary I got rid of everthing I hadn’t worn in a year. It felt so good I decieded to work it down to just clothes I really need. I had 6 short sets! 6 I can only wear one at a time so I donated 3 to Goodwill. Why the obseesion with buying clothes and having a closet full? I can find something to wear so much easier now.. U always inspire me!
August 12th, 2010 at 2:35 am
Where I live we have a cafe with a free box. It’s like a trading market for getting rid of what you’re tired of and finding new treasures without buying a thing. I’ve participated in a few clothes trading parties as well where everyone brings a bag of the clothing they don’t want, everybody dumps everything out on a table, and then digs through it to find “new” things to take home.
Because I love flea markets I often end up doing a sort of trade of mw own there. I like to switch things up a lot, so I will buy items at a flea market (my rule is never to pay more than 1 euro for any flea market clothing) that I like and then later I set up my own stand and sell all the bits I’ve gotten tired of to other bargain hunters!
August 27th, 2010 at 7:58 pm
You posted this while I was on vacation and I am just seeing it now! Very interesting…and I think the parallel about how being unhappy with your clothes can lead to being unhappy with yourself is very true. It is so important to be happy with what we have!